The Tiger Musky is a gigantic fish, and in fact the largest member of the Esox family. Which is double impressive when you consider they share the same family as the vaunted northern pike and muskellunge.
The tiger musky is hybrid fish that results from a pike and a musky breeding. They are normally bred in hatcheries however sometimes a tiger musky does occur naturally in the wild. These fish combine features of a northern pike and musky and can grow larger than both.
Generally this fish is catch and release wherever you find it because of the very low numbers. But if you hook one of these you’ll remember as a big one will give you the fight of a lifetime even as an avid angler!
How to Identify a Tiger Musky
Woo boy, this one can be tough. There isn’t a set way that a tiger muskie is going to look compared to a northern pike or a regular muskie. There might be certain common patterns in a local area or body of water, but not a hard and fast rule.
So let’s start with two things you MUST know if you are going to have any chance of accurately identifying a tiger muskie.
There are certain traits that only pike have, as well as certain traits that only muskies have.
Knowing these traits is important because a muskie will not have pike only traits just as pike will not have muskie only traits. This can help you spot red flags when the coloring is wrong on that so-called pike or that muskie has rounded fins like a northern.
Once in a while it’s an obvious mis-mash. That being said, here are some of the best/easiest common patterns to look for if you want to know if a fish is a tiger muskie or not.
Look for obvious dual patterns
If one fish has a really obvious pattern that is northern pike, and another that is clearly muskellunge then you are almost certainly dealing with a tiger muskie.
Sometimes it is actually that easy, though many times it is not.
The color pattern is switched
This isn’t a 100%, but it is a really likely give away. Many muskies have dark markings with a lighter background color. This is the opposite of a northern pike, which has light markings on a darker background skin.
So if you catch a fish that has all the patterns of a pike, but it has dark markings on a light skin, that might be the tiger muskie that anglers affectionately refer to as a “Tiger Pike” because of its appearance.
That fish is indeed a tiger muskie.
Pike with a huge head
This is also a tell that you might have a “tiger pike” version of a tiger muskie versus a regular northern. Even on the biggest muskie or pike the head is about 1/3 of the body at most. On tiger muskie the head area is much bigger and can be up to half the non fin body.
If you catch a “pike” with an oddly huge head, there’s a decent chance it’s a tiger muskie.
Switching patterns on the fish
The first half has the bars of a muskie, the second half has the dots of a pike. Or vice-versa. Some beautiful tiger muskies actually have the pattern on their body that changes.
If you have a fish where half the body has a muskie pattern and half has a northern pattern then that’s a dead giveaway that you’re dealing with a hybrid.
Rounded fins on a muskie
Pike have rounded fins, but muskies have sharp fins. So when you see a muskie with rounded fins…it’s probably not because something was chewing on them. Rounded fins on a muskie is a dead giveaway that you’re actually dealing with a tiger muskie instead.
Copyright information for the above pictures:
- Copyright Jeff Van Remortel – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6rStqnJ5hK8&ab_channel=JeffVanRemortel
- Copyright Musky Mastery – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ledPE5N7zAE&ab_channel=MuskyMastery
- Public Domain from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
- Tiger Muskie 1 By BenitoJuarez98 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=46011085
Wait, Tiger Musky or Tiger Pike?
In some lakes the majority of features on the tiger muskie will actually look like a northern pike, but there will be one or two “small” giveaways that prove the fish is not actually a northern.
There is no “tiger pike” although that is an affectionate name that some anglers give to tiger muskies that look way more like northern pikes than like muskies.
For middle sized fish make sure you’re not looking at a pickerel-pike hybrid.
However in other cases this is still a tiger muskie. As cool as the name is, “tiger pike” is not a sub-species of the pike family.
Where Can You Find Tiger Muskies?
Like most hybrids in nature, tiger muskies can’t breed. They’re sterile. While they can, and do, occur naturally where there are decent sized populations of both muskies and northern pike, the overwhelming number of tiger muskies out in the wild are bred in hatcheries.
These are a mazing game fish and they can be more effectively and efficiently created and grown in hatcheries before being released than they can occur in the wild.
This means that finding one that came about in the wild really is a cool rarity.
This also means there are state sponsored programs to breed and stock bodies of water where these fish can thrive without throwing off the local natural balance.
Keep an eye on local stocking operations and make sure to follow all catch and release regulations in the area while fishing.
That’s it. One of the most interesting things about this hybrid is how hard it can be to understand what you have at first glance. Some look like an exact 50/50 mixture of pike and muskie.
However, there are some nicknamed “tiger pike” because only one or two traits and their sheer size gives away that the fish isn’t a pike. There are also those who look a lot like a musky but are just a touch off.
Tiger muskies are an amazing fish and you will spend thousands of casts just getting your shot at a single one but when the big tiger muskie finally hits you will know that the wait was well worth it!